Well we are back for Part 2 of our ‘Hardwax Oil Experiment’ where we are extensively testing and reviewing the 3 top hard wax oils available in the States, specifically Illinois. Last month we did a review on OSMO Hardwax Oil ( click here if you missed it). This month we are going to do an in-depth Rubio Monocoat review.
Rubio Monocoat Oil is imported from Belgium. Here’s a rundown of the features and benefits from the Rubio Monocoat marketing material:
That’s quite an impressive list.
The one feature that had us the most curious was the claim of only one coat. This claim is completely new and foreign to hardwood floor refinishing guys. Usually we use systems that comprise of at least three coats – a sealer of some sort and then at least two top coats. To have a complete system with only one coat and still be durable was something we eagerly wanted to try out.
Here’s how they explain how the one coat system works on their website:
“Monocoat adheres with the first microns of wood by molecular bonding… because of molecular bonding, no surface film can form, and no variable saturation can occur. Not only is a second coat not required, the finished wood will not accept a second coat.”
We were about to see if this truly is the case…
Like the first hardwax oil test subject (OSMO hardwax oil), we began our experiment in our workshop on various sample boards. After some time spent testing we had our first sample boards ready to go. As you can imagine with just one coat, the application was quite easy. The big thing with this system that will make or break it though is the surface preparation – we’ll get to that in a bit. The durability was impressive as we did all we could to scratch and damage it. VOC’s were non-existent (a huge plus) and the smell was just a light oil scent. Step one passed, onto the next stage…
The next step was to find a floor to test it out on in the real world. The first floor we used Monocoat on was a red oak rift cut hardwood floor in Clarendon Hills, Illinois. We used the Dark Oak colored oil.
You can see how it turned out below…
The following photo shows the shine – or rather the lack of it. This finish system has an extremely matte finish and no plastic surface build up at all…
Our next floor where we used Monocoat Oil was in Kenilworth, Illinois – a nice red oak floor that needed to be sanded and refinished. The owner wanted to use environmentally friendly products and was more than happy to try out the new Rubio Monocoat oil system after seeing the sample boards.
This floor was going to be a little special too because we were going to put a diamond pattern in the kitchen dining room. You can see the pattern all laid out with tape below (after the floors were sanded and prepped)…
Here’s the finished floor below. The client chose the Smoke and Oyster colors to make the diamond pattern. The owner was extremely happy with the floor and the finish which is always good…
And here’s another job we did in Naperville, Illinois on white oak floors…
The client chose the ‘Smoke’ color. You can see the nice matte sheen this finish has in the photo below…
… and here’s a close up to show a bit more of the detail…
Well let’s go back and review the basics of what we look for in a finish:
Let’s go through each of these one-by-one below to see how Rubio Monocoat faired…
Looks are very subjective and like everything, will depend on your own tastes. If you like the look of a thick “plastic” finish and like some sheen, then you may not like this finish. The sheen of Rubio Monocoat oil is very matte – in other words there is no gloss at all. Personally we like the look. It looks very natural and really enhances the beauty of your timber’s natural grain. It’s a nice option compared to all the plastic looking finishes out there.
If you want a bit more of a sheen, there’s another product called Soap Satin that is applied as a second coat that will give it a bit more of a satin sheen (this will add another day to the process).
The other aspect of good looks are the colors available. With over 30 basic color choices you’ll have no trouble getting the specific look you want if you would like something more unique as well. How many finishes can you get in blues, reds, greens and greys?
Here are some of the basic color choices…
For even more choice there are pre-color treatments you can use to create cool contrasting effects on your floor that mix two colors together.
If you have oak or ash floors then the oil colors can be also mixed with a process called ‘Smoked’ to give you even more cool options. It reacts to the tannic acid in the wood to create very unique effects like you can see below…
As well there is another process called ‘Fumed’ which provide an ammonia smoked aspect to Oak or Ash floors that allows you to be even more creative with your hardwood floors…
As you can start to see, using Monocoat Oil opens up a huge choice of colors and design choices. You can also apply different designs using different colors like our diamond patterned floor shown above. You’ll only be limited by your imagination.
This one is a biggie because no-one wants to spend a small fortune getting their hardwood floors sanded and refinished and then find out that the coating system they chose doesn’t live up to their expectations. Many unsuspecting homeowners have had cheap, inadequate oil based and single component water based finishes applied only to find out down the road they are wearing out prematurely.
Other homeowners love the look of traditional oil finishes but then find out that they need constant maintenance to keep their protective qualities, which can become a real pain.
With Rubio Monocoat you get the best of both types of finishes – the beautiful looks of traditional oil finishes and the durability of a higher end surface finish. As the oil is applied it molecularly bonds to the wood and leaves a matte surface that offers a strong protective coating. No matter what is done to it, it won’t crack, flake, peel, blister or panelize like conventional surface finishes. It’s resistance to spills is extremely impressive too.
Is it as durable as our favorite Pall-X96 and X98 finish systems?
But… and this is a big but… the best feature of Rubio Hardwax Oil is that if there is damage done it can be spot repaired – which brings us to our next point…
As we talked about in Part 1 of our ‘Hardwax Oil Experiment’, easy maintenance is one of the reasons thick surface finishes are so popular and old world penetrating oil systems are not. Liquids spilled on a “plastic” finish can be easily wiped up. Cleaning is easy with a damp mop or cloth, and a Swiffer type of broom or a soft bristled vacuum quickly takes care of dust in-between washes.
But as we already talked about in depth in Part 1, the strength of this system is also its greatest weakness. Because these finishes are basically a big “plastic” sheet spread out across the entire floor when they dry, major damage like deep scratches are very hard to repair properly if you want to blend in the repair with the rest of the floor.
Monocoat oil on the other hand, can be spot repaired in the middle of the room and it would be very difficult to know there was any damage there afterwards. This is because only the open (damaged) wood fibers will take the touch-up coating. The existing finish next to the scratched or damaged area will not accept new oil. There is no overlapping or additional buildup and the sheen will blend in perfectly. As you can imagine, this is a huge benefit of this finish system.
Because of the great durability and easy maintenance, many highly trafficked public spaces use this system – including the Hermitage museum in Amsterdam, the W-hotel in Dallas, the Four Seasons Hotel in Biltmore and Google offices all over the world. That’s some pretty impressive clients!
If you look after and properly maintain your floors with this finish system, they will last a lifetime and you’ll never need to re-sand your floors ever again. You’ll just need to periodically maintain them by touching up the inevitable scratches, dings and marks. Rubio provides a special cleaner that works perfectly with the finish. Basically it’s the sheen adding Soap Satin product, but diluted down to be used as a cleaning agent. If you originally used the Soap Satin on your floors to give them some sheen then from time-to-time you’ll want to re-apply it when the sheen starts to dull.
You won’t have to move out all of your furniture each time as the worn out pathways are the only areas needing attention. It’s far easier than maintaining a traditional oil finish every couple of months and also way less hassle compared to completely re-sanding and refinishing your entire hardwood floors every 7 to 10 years if you have a lower-end surface finish.
The vegetable oils used in the finish are claimed as being non-yellowing so you don’t have to worry about that ugly “old” look after a couple of years that you can get with polyurethane oil modified finishes.
While we’re sure they’ll stand up to UV light better than oil modified finishes, we’ll have to wait a while to see if these claims are 100% true. Our initial findings are that it’s doing a good job so far in this regard.
Rubio Monocoat oil wood floor finishes are completely VOC free and completely natural and non-toxic. There is a mild vegetable oil smell initially that is not bothersome at all. Apart from the easy maintenance, this will be the next best feature for a lot of people, especially those that are planning to stay at home while the floors are being refinished.
It’s also gaining fast popularity within the green building community because it contains no VOC’s. It also doesn’t contain: formaldehyde, ammonia, acetone, solvents, odor-masking agents, chemical residuals, arsenic, beryllium, chromium, cadmium, nickel or lead. You only have to use warm water and soap to clean up after use.
Anything that helps the environment and makes for a more pleasant experience in the midst of the hassle of having your floors sanded and refinished sounds good to us.
This hardwax oil takes a bit longer to dry than the OSMO we first tested. From 24 to 36 hours for it to be completely dry. As it’s a 1 coat system it’s a lot faster than the time of a 3 coat water-based system and is much faster than a 3 coat oil-based system. It’s also faster than the 2 coat OSMO system. Nobody wants their floors out of commission for too long so it’s definitely a win in our books for client convenience. The only time it will take a bit longer than the 36 hours to dry is if you want to add the second product to give it a satin sheen. This will add 12 more hours of drying time.
We think it did extremely well. It’s an extremely flexible system that has a great choice of colors, it has no dangerous ingredients, doesn’t stink and is durable as well as extremely easy to maintain.
Here’s a pretty informative video from the company that provides a good review of this system (especially the part between the 1 minute and 2 minute section) – although I love how they breeze over the most important part… the sanding and surface preparation 🙂
Anyone that wants one of the most environmentally friendly finishes available in the world will love this system. Anyone that wants a completely unique floor will love it too.
This would also be a great finish for a commercial environment like a restaurants, hotels or offices where speed and smell are major concerns. In fact we have a project coming up that this is just prefect for – a real estate agent office. They work Monday to Saturday and can’t afford to shut the offices down other than on Sunday. With any other finish system this would be impossible, if not just for the drying time and number of coats needed.
With Rubio Monocoat, we can come in after the office closes on Saturday evening, sand the hardwood floors through the night, apply the oil early Sunday morning and then have them dry and ready for opening Monday. When they need maintenance or touch-ups we can always do that on a Sunday so there is no disruption. This system really is incredible for situations like these.
Like all finishes, there are certain situations where we would advise our clients not to use them as well. For numerous reasons we can chat about in person when we come out to look at your floors, we would not be comfortable using Monocoat Oil on older floors that are excessively chipped, splintered gapped and damaged.
We’ll only apply it to floors that are in good condition, relatively gap free and that can be sanded to a smooth, flat and even surface. As we mentioned at the start of this article, a very high standard of surface preparation is crucial to make this finish look its best. As we’re perfectionists we won’t apply a finish that we know we can’t do justice to and that you won’t be happy with.
It’s also not the appropriate finish for those that love the “glossy, shiny and thick” finish look. This finish is very flat and gives a hand-rubbed look. If you use the Soap Satin as a second coat you’ll get a bit more sheen, but it will never be a shiny finish. This finish is for people that love the natural look and feel of timber and want to highlight it and not have it covered up by ‘plastic’.
We are definitely impressed with Rubio Monocoat Oil. It has overcome many issues that other traditional finishes battle with. We love the creativity that this finish allows as well as the air quality and environmental benefits. The easy maintenance is also a huge plus.
Is it for everyone… no. But then again what finish system is? For those that see the benefits that it offers, it could be the perfect system though.
We have two more hardwax oil finishes to test out and report back on for this experiment – Pallmann Magic Oil and Bona Indoor Oil . We’ll get to those during the next two months. When we’ve done that we’ll see which one will join the ranks of being a Tadas Wood Flooring recommended finish.
If you have any questions about Rubio Monocoat we’ll be more than happy to discuss it over the phone or in person. If you book an In-Home Audit with us then you’ll also get to see the samples we put together. One way or the other we’ll help you decide on the perfect finish system for your floors.
(Continue to Part 3 to see the results of the next review – Bona Indoor Oil)